What is included
Reading the inspection report
The PCAOB's guide to its inspection reports explains how each report is organized:
| Part | What it contains | Public? |
| Part I.A | Audits where, in the inspectors' view, the firm had not obtained sufficient appropriate evidence to support its opinion on the financial statements and/or ICFR. Issuers are identified by letter, not by name. | Yes |
| Part I.B | Other non-compliance with PCAOB standards or rules, such as audit committee communications under AS 1301 or Form AP reporting. | Yes |
| Part I.C | Recent reports may include potential non-compliance with independence requirements. | Yes |
| Part II | Criticisms of, or potential defects in, the firm's system of quality control. | Only if not remediated in time |
Under Section 104(g)(2), Part II stays nonpublic if the firm addresses the criticisms to the Board's satisfaction within 12 months of the report date. If it does not, the PCAOB reissues Part II publicly. The PCAOB also notes that an audit deficiency does not necessarily mean the financial statements are materially misstated.
Impact assessment for the issuer
When an audit is cited, the auditor has to decide whether it can still support its opinion. Today that assessment is governed by AS 2901 (omitted procedures). If facts come to light that would have affected the report, AS 2905 applies. A replacement AS 2901, Responding to Engagement Deficiencies After Issuance of the Auditor's Report, is listed by the PCAOB as effective on December 15, 2026. Working with management and the audit committee, we help assess:
- Which accounts and assertions were affected, and whether there are signs of a misstatement.
- Whether the additional work can be done by the existing auditor, or whether a change or re-audit is more realistic.
- Possible knock-on effects on ICFR conclusions, material weakness assessments and disclosure controls.
When a re-audit is needed
A re-audit is generally needed when the predecessor's registration has been revoked, when the firm has ceased operations and cannot reissue its report, or when significant restatement adjustments are involved. The SEC staff's Financial Reporting Manual, Topic 4 discusses each of these situations. Your securities counsel should confirm what must be disclosed and filed.
How a successor auditor approaches it
If the company changes firms, we follow the auditor change process: Form 8-K Item 4.01, Item 304 disclosures and the inquiries required by PCAOB AS 2610. We treat the inspection finding as a risk factor. Affected areas get more testing, opening balances in those areas get extra attention, and we do not rely on the predecessor's conclusions.
Questions for the audit committee
- Was our audit inspected, and what were the results, including any Part I.B items?
- What did the firm do in response, and did it change its opinion or its scope?
- Has the firm received Part II criticisms, and were they remediated within 12 months?
- Has our engagement partner been inspected on other audits, and with what results?
- What changes will we see in staffing, review and timing this year?
The PCAOB's resources for audit committees include further suggested questions. The PCAOB also says it reaches out each year to audit committee chairs at U.S. public companies whose audits it inspects.